Skip to content
Search

Drake’s Label Fires Back at Rapper in Appeals Court: ‘Astoundingly Hypocritical’

Universal Music Group says Kendrick Lamar's lyrics calling Drake a pedophile represent "classic opinion," and Drake's attempt to revive his defamation lawsuit should fail

Drake’s Label Fires Back at Rapper in Appeals Court: ‘Astoundingly Hypocritical’

Drake on July 12, 2025 in London, England.

Simone Joyner/Getty Images

Universal Music Group is firing back at Drake again, arguing in a new appellate brief that the rapper’s attempt to revive his failed defamation lawsuit over Kendrick Lamar’s “Not Like Us” is illogical and “astoundingly hypocritical.”


In its new 83-page filing obtained by Rolling Stone, UMG says the Canadian rapper born Aubrey Drake Graham is making arguments so flawed and “nonsensical” that he’s attempting to “turn the law upside down.” The new brief, filed in the Second Circuit, argues U.S. District Judge Jeannette A. Vargas ruled correctly last October when she concluded that Lamar’s lyrics calling Drake a pedophile were “nonactionable opinion,” meaning not statements of fact.

The label says Drake clearly felt free to use UMG’s platform to attack Lamar “in equally incendiary terms” when it suited him, but now he’s seeking a different standard for the “words he now dislikes” that were directed at him. “[Drake] seeks to strip words from their context and deem them actionable defamation if anyone, anywhere, might treat them as factual. That is not the law, and Drake’s view would critically undermine a highly creative art form built on exaggeration, insult, and wordplay,” the new filing argues.

In her ruling dismissing Drake’s lawsuit last fall, Judge Vargas found that Lamar’s lyrics were delivered as a “direct callback to Drake’s lyrics” amid “a heated rap battle with incendiary language and offensive accusations hurled by both participants.” She determined a reasonable listener would conclude Lamar was “rapping hyperbolic vituperations,” not “verifiable facts.”

“The issue in this case is whether ‘Not Like Us’ can reasonably be understood to convey as a factual matter that Drake is a pedophile or that he has engaged in sexual relations with minors,” Vargas wrote. “In light of the overall context in which the statements in the recording were made, the court holds that it cannot.”

The nine-track rap battle at the center of the legal war started making headlines in April 2024. It exploded when Drake released “Family Matters” on May 3, 2024, accusing Lamar of domestic abuse and not being the father of one of his kids. Lamar responded with the back-to-back drops of “Meet the Grahams” and “Not Like Us,” with the latter’s hook of “certified lover boy, certified pedophile” becoming an instant and viral sensation.

UMG says the court was correct to emphasize that the nine songs were “in dialogue with one another.” It notes that Lamar’s line, “Say, Drake, I hear you like ’em young,” was an obvious response to Drake’s lyrics in “Taylor Made Freestyle,” which taunted Lamar to repeat rumors that Drake had dated someone underage. “Talk about him likin’ young girls,” Drake says in the track.

“As much as Drake may dislike that context after the fact, it is fair game and critical to consider under New York law,” UMG and its lawyers argue in the new filing.

The label also calls it “nonsensical” for Drake to argue that Lamar’s lyrics could be defamatory because rap lyrics are sometimes admitted as evidence in criminal cases. UMG says that context, in which a jury is asked to make factual determinations under different legal standards, is distinct. In any event, the label notes, Drake signed a November 2022 petition criticizing prosecutors for treating artists’ creative expression as fact.

“Drake’s argument is also astoundingly hypocritical,” the filing states. It cites the petition’s claim that “more than any other art form, rap lyrics are essentially being used as confessions in an attempt to criminalize Black creativity and artistry,” and that such use “is un-American and simply wrong.” The filing suggests Drake is now taking the opposite position to serve his interests.

In his 60-page appeal brief in January, Drake renewed his argument that Lamar’s track states, as a “precise” and “unambiguous matter of fact,” that Drake is a “certified pedophile.” He claimed UMG “relentlessly” marketed “Not Like Us” in a way that misled consumers and caused him serious harm. He said Lamar’s lyrics are “capable of being proven true or false,” so his lawsuit belongs in front of a jury.

Drake and his lawyers further claimed the dismissal of his lawsuit could have far-reaching negative consequences by creating a “dangerous categorical rule” that would shield artists and labels from liability no matter how extreme or damaging their accusations might be. UMG responded Friday by claiming that argument “blatantly mischaracterizes” Judge Vargas’ ruling.

“It nowhere indicated that a diss track could never be defamatory; it simply recognized that the ‘average listener’ in this forum and ‘common expectation’ for statements in this forum were significant,” UMG’s filing says. “It held, including in light of those considerations, that this diss track could not be understood by a reasonable listener as conveying fact.”

Drake originally sued UMG in January 2025, accusing the label of promoting Lamar’s hit song in a way that “intended to convey the specific, unmistakable, and false factual allegation that Drake is a criminal pedophile.” He notably sued only the record label he shares with Lamar, not Lamar himself.

UMG responded with a pair of scathing motions to dismiss that ultimately prevailed. “Plaintiff, one of the most successful recording artists of all time, lost a rap battle that he provoked and in which he willingly participated,” lawyers for UMG wrote. “Instead of accepting the loss like the unbothered rap artist he often claims to be, he has sued his own record label in a misguided attempt to salve his wounds.”

“Not Like Us” went on to win Grammy Awards for Record and Song of the Year, becoming only the third hip-hop song to win Record of the Year after Childish Gambino’s “This Is America,” and Lizzo’s “About Damn Time.” Lamar also performed the song during the widely viewed 2025 Super Bowl halftime show.

Drake is expected to respond to UMG’s new appellate filing with a reply brief due April 17.

More Stories

The Beatles Celebrate Liverpool in New Video for ‘In My Life’
Laura Lewis

The Beatles Celebrate Liverpool in New Video for ‘In My Life’

The Beatles celebrate their hometown of Liverpool in the new video for the Fab Four classic “In My Life.”

Keep ReadingShow less
The Weeknd and Justice Have an Unreleased Song on the 'GTA VI' Score

The Weeknd and Justice Have an Unreleased Song on the 'GTA VI' Score

A new collaboration between The Weeknd and Justice has been found on the airwaves of Grand Theft Auto VI. Titled "My Only Vice," the unreleased track brings together Toronto's Abel Tesfaye and the French electronic duo for Rockstar Games' new blockbuster.

Keep ReadingShow less
White Lotus Actor Adam DiMarco Announces Debut EP as hockeysuperstar

White Lotus Actor Adam DiMarco Announces Debut EP as hockeysuperstar

Adam DiMarco, the Canadian actor who played in the second season of HBO’s The White Lotus, grew up, like most Torontonians, a hockey-obsessed kid. So much so that when came time to come up with an email adress as a child, he chose the handle ''hockeysuperstar'', which is now the name of his musical project.

Keep ReadingShow less
Rejoice: Phoebe Bridgers Rings in the Holidays With an Adrianne Lenker Cover

Phoebe Bridgers attends the “Primetime” Photocall during the 83rd Venice International Film Festival at Palazzo del Casino on September 05, 2026 in Venice, Italy.

Stefania D'Alessandro/WireImage

Rejoice: Phoebe Bridgers Rings in the Holidays With an Adrianne Lenker Cover

It’s been several years since Phoebe Bridgers released her annual holiday cover, but the singer-songwriter has resumed the tradition, dropping her take on Adrianne Lenker‘s “Anything.”

Keep ReadingShow less
CMA Awards 2026: The Complete Winners List

Ella Langley won Entertainer of the Year at the 2026 CMA Awards.

Cindy Ord/Getty Images

CMA Awards 2026: The Complete Winners List

The 60th annual CMA Awards aired live from Nashville on Wednesday, Nov. 18. Ella Langley was the leading nominee, with nine, and the Alabama singer nearly ran the board. She took home Single of the Year and Song of the Year for her juggernaut hit “Choosin’ Texas,” and Music Video of the Year for the song’s video. Langley also won Album of the Year for Dandelion, and was named Female Vocalist of the Year. The biggest surprise was when Langley’s name was called for the night’s top prize: Entertainer of the Year.

Keep ReadingShow less